Steven Price

My book

Media Minefield

Guide to NZ Media Law

Official Information Act

Official Information Act

Bill of Rights Act

Media law resources

Feeds (RSS)

« | Main | »

Comments on Rogers case

By Steven | November 21, 2007

The missing angle in the media

Did anyone in the media report that virtually all the Supreme Court judges seem to believe that, as Blanchard J puts it, “the police would appear to have acted beyond their powers” in releasing the videotaped confession to the media, because they are required to treat evidence as secret unless there is some operational reason to disclose it? Police illegally leaking material to the media? Isn’t that a bit… topical?

The missing angle in the judgments

The police gave the video to the media after TVNZ had asked them for it. Isn’t that… an Official Information request? If the resulting handover of the tape was in good faith, then section 48 applies to protect the police and the media from civil or criminal proceedings for making it available “or for any consequences that follow from the making available of that information.” (Still, it wouldn’t prevent TVNZ being sued for breach of confidence: see section 48(2).) This section is a bit complicated, and my analysis here is superficial. But my point is that surely it’s relevant, though it didn’t get a mention.

This was fairly close

The judges decided 3-2 to allow the broadcast. Two would have continued the injunction and sent the case back to the High Court. One wonders whether any of the other three might have been tempted to do the same thing, but were embarrassed to do so given the length of time it has taken them (damn near a year) to put out this judgment.

The case is a mess

The parties never produced pleadings to clarify the issues. Several important evidential issues had not been resolved. For example, it wasn’t clear on what conditions TVNZ received the tape. The police were given leave to withdraw from the case early on. What should have been treated as an interlocutory decision (ie a holding-pattern case prior to trial) was treated as a final decision (disposing of the case for good.) The Supreme Court produced five different judgments. Two of them moan about the process that had been followed and would have sent it back. Three of them launch on a hypothetical discussion about what would have happened if TVNZ had made an application under the search rules (an exercise the Chief Justice slams as “having no very sound foundation”). I’m inclined to think this case isn’t much of a precedent for anything.

What about the Court of Appeal’s decision to exclude the videotaped confession?

Reading between the lines, it looks like at least some of the Supreme Court judges think the CA got that right. Blanchard J describes the police breaches as “grave”.

Does the case affect the privacy tort?

Not really. Justice Anderson tries to explain that he agrees with the Chief Justice that the existence and scope of the tort of invasion of privacy is still an open question “and will fall to be reviewed by this Court in an appropriate case”. You’ll remember that he was in the minority in Hosking v Runting. He thought there should be no such tort.

He’s right that the Supremes will have the last word on that. But he’s stretching things a bit to say that the Chief Justice doubts the “existence” of the tort. She says that the “limits” of the tort are not firmly settled. (Interestingly, she casts doubt on whether we need an element that publication be offensive, as well as the element that there must be a reasonable expectation of privacy. This change would potentially expand the tort). I can’t see that the CJ anywhere casts doubt on the existence of the tort.

The other judges simply apply Hosking and say that Rogers could have no reasonable expectation of privacy in a confession video. There seems to be a tentative convergence toward the time of the making of the video as the time at which the reasonable expectation has to arise. This must still be regarded as being in doubt. The CJ cites overseas authority suggesting that it’s the time of publication that’s relevant.

There seems to be some disagreement about the injunction threshold for privacy cases. Tipping J says the position is “broadly analogous” to defamation (ie very hard to get an injunction if you assert any sort of defence) [66]. The CJ suggests that injunctions ought to be granted more readily in privacy cases [38], saying that the analogy is imperfect, since a failure to grant an injunction in privacy cases means the ballgame is over.

Congratulations to Nicole Moreham and John Burrows

…who picked this as a breach of confidence case, if anything. That’s what the CJ and Anderson say. The other judges don’t really disagree, they just note that it wasn’t argued on that basis.

I’d have to say that given that there’s a strong flavour of public interest that comes through most of the decisions, it’s hard to see how it would be any different under breach of confidence. I’d also wonder whether the material is “obviously confidential” under the Spycatcher case (cited by the CJ) given that (a) the contents of the video had been described publicly and in a judgment and (b) TVNZ was on the scene when it was made.

Hypothetical consideration of a search application – legitimate?

Three judges asked themselves what they would have done had this been an application under the search rules for access to the video. MAYBE we should read this as a way of saying, well, if TVNZ could ask for it now and be given it, then the rest of the argument doesn’t matter much. That might be okay. But in fact, they seem to go further. They seem to import all the factors that they would apply to a search application to the test for an injunction against the media who already have the tape. Isn’t that different? What rule of law are the courts referring to when they give themselves the power to restrain the media on the basis of a hypothetical application that the media don’t need to make? Isn’t the starting point that they should be able to use it unless there’s some law that can be used to restrain them? It may be comforting that the judges come to the conclusion that the search application would have been successful. But what about the next case?

McGrath J goes further (and Tipping J indicates agreement with McGrath’s reasoning). He says the courts have the power to restrain the use of the tape as an abuse of the court’s process. That seems like a long bow to me. I might have a bit of a bias: with this piece of dicta, McGrath has called into question the principle laid down in the case I argued (Hunt v A) that a person who obtains material from the court record from a party is free to publish it without making a search application.

Use of the Bill of Rights Act – legitimate?

This is also a bit startling. The judges seem ready to consider the proposition that excluding evidence from a court may not be a sufficient remedy when it has been illegally obtained. They contemplate the possibility of restraining the media (where here, there is no evidence that it did anything unlawful in acquiring the evidence) from broadcasting it – as part of a remedy for the police breach of the defendant’s rights. Again, they find that excluding the evidence is sufficient vindication of the rights breached (right to silence; right to consult a lawyer). But again, they seem to leave open the possibility in a future case, I think. I would have thought the starting point would have been, again, to ask whether there is any law that prevents publication, and then to ask whether its application in the circumstances would be a proportionate restriction on the media’s right to freedom of expression.

It’s a bit murky, and I may not have read the case closely enough. But I guess what I’m saying is that this case is no ringing endorsement of the right to free speech and open justice. Fair to say, though, that the facts of the case are very unusual, as is the process that was followed. So I’m not sure it stands for anything much. And there’s lots of useful dicta about how court decisions aren’t the last word on a person’s guilt or innocence: the media have the right to ask those questions for themselves afterward, and the importance of allowing the public to see the actual evidence in such cases. (What I don’t like, though, is the continuing idea that if the public get to sit in on the case, that’s enough for open justice. As I’ve said before, what if the significance of the case only becomes apparent afterwards? It may be only then that a journalist can really get his or her teeth into it – and the public interest may well require access to the evidence.)

Topics: Breach of confidence, Contempt of Court, Court records, Injunctions, NZ Bill of Rights Act, Official Information Act, Privacy tort | 51 Comments »

51 Responses to “Comments on Rogers case”

  1. white long sleeve wedding dress Says:
    November 8th, 2018 at 10:31 pm

    white long sleeve wedding dress

    nike air max 2011 womens tumblr.comred white and blue air max 95 tumblr.comwomens winter jackets onlinewomens where to buy lebron jersey

  2. other shoes roseonly Says:
    November 28th, 2018 at 8:49 pm

    other shoes roseonly

    cheap soccer cleats nike mercurial vapor x fgasics asics gelkayano 22nba shoes lebron soldier 10adidas neo label

  3. zapatillas innovative nike Says:
    December 17th, 2018 at 10:09 am

    zapatillas innovative nike

    converse dennis rodman all star shoesnike air max cage womens tennis shoes whitemetallic whitenike s zoom kobe persian violet kobe bryant volt black black x mens sneakers romanticpuma faas 500 blacktender shootsisland green shoes 1

  4. adidas originals men s adidas originals snapback cap trefoil in black black white 5 panel Says:
    December 18th, 2018 at 1:45 pm

    adidas originals men s adidas originals snapback cap trefoil in black black white 5 panel

    adidas has been celta vigo s kit supplier since the 2012 13 season while the club s kits were recently also made by umbro and li ningsoccer uniforms apparel manufacturing cut sew sublimationjimmy graham seattle seahawks nike vapor untouchable color rus…

  5. prezzo pi霉 basso uomo air jordan 13 j13 retro bianco verde scarpe air max bambino prezzo Says:
    August 17th, 2019 at 5:54 pm

    prezzo pi霉 basso uomo air jordan 13 j13 retro bianco verde scarpe air max bambino prezzo

    dettagli. scarpe da calcio nike a poco prezzopacote com 4 alfabetos manuscrito completo. matriz d bordado noversace scarpe donna moda 2017 velvetstylescarpe casadei usate

  6. zegarek tommy hilfiger gracie 178.12.14 orygina艂 z艂oty Says:
    January 9th, 2020 at 6:24 am

    zegarek tommy hilfiger gracie 178.12.14 orygina艂 z艂oty

    reflektor led z funkcj膮 艣ledzenia ruchu livarno luxgeox torrence obu膰a za cipelerezz. original palladium cipele cizme啪enske majice i tunike u trgovini na

  7. womens fringe faux leather jacket black s collection b Says:
    January 17th, 2020 at 3:04 am

    womens fringe faux leather jacket black s collection b

    hunter pence san francisco giants cream goldenwomens new era black baltimore orioles 9twenty core classic twill adjustable hatwhat if bryan shaw occupied every single roster spot inunder armour texas rangers youth royal tech t shirt

  8. rhonda shear 3 pack pin up bra Says:
    January 17th, 2020 at 6:54 pm

    rhonda shear 3 pack pin up bra

    leopard print stretch satin headbandwyse london ines slouchy rainbow cashmere jumperbeach cooler 550695 lilly pulitzermcm bag essential monogram large cocoa pink leather tote 34 off retail

  9. victorias secret love pink new york mets bling hat baseball cap bling Says:
    January 18th, 2020 at 9:59 pm

    victorias secret love pink new york mets bling hat baseball cap bling

    sweat homme blundstonesweat shirts vetement femme pas cher en ligneorange label aop sweat 脿 capuchegilet 脿 capuche zipp茅 vert ed hardy c. audigier taille xl

  10. paul smith iphone pouch Says:
    January 22nd, 2020 at 8:55 am

    paul smith iphone pouch

    paul smith unique mens dress socks18ct white gold 2.22ct aquamarine diamond emerald cut ringepoca blue dial and brown leather strap mens watchcompare buy paul smith suits in singapore 2019 best

  11. nfl jacksonville jaguars womens football Says:
    January 25th, 2020 at 10:37 am

    nfl jacksonville jaguars womens football

    lego batman movie mime minifigure 71017 20 new genuine rareused lego creator red house 3n1 set 4956 78.00 picclickphilippine bricksters lego creator 31066 space roverrare lego sets for sale rare lego set 6653

  12. balenciaga track s black red Says:
    January 25th, 2020 at 1:42 pm

    balenciaga track s black red

    銈儶銈搞儕銉偪銈儷銈掋儑銈躲偆銉崇劇鏂欍仹瑁戒綔 銈儶銈搞儕銉偪銈儷浣滄垚灏傞杸2way 銉曘儸銈偣銉兗銉杤銉嶃儍銈儻銉炽償銉笺偣涓彜 united arrows tokyo銇儸銉囥偅銉笺偣 銈广偒銉笺儓 銉併偋銉冦偗銉曘儸銈偣銈兗銉?/a>妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 闀疯病甯?銈广儕銉冦儣銉溿偪銉?銉儑銈c兗銈?銉栥儵銉炽儔銈般儍銉?/a>

  13. 转讬拽 讙讘 讗讜专讟讜驻讚讬 38l 诇讘讬讛 住 谞讬讬讚 讟讬讜诇讬诐 诪讜转讙 keep ahead Says:
    January 26th, 2020 at 12:50 am

    转讬拽 讙讘 讗讜专讟讜驻讚讬 38l 诇讘讬讛 住 谞讬讬讚 讟讬讜诇讬诐 诪讜转讙 keep ahead

    men women winter warm beanie hat rock metallica acdc rock band warm winter knitted beanies hat cap for adult men womencome realizzare bomboniere fai da te fai da2 western cowboy mini hats car mirror novelty hatthule krovni nosa膷i za toyota corolla

  14. tenisice Nike Air Force 2 Shadow hr Says:
    February 1st, 2020 at 1:21 am

    tenisice Nike Air Force 2 Shadow hr

    tenisice NASA hr

  15. herschel supply co. highland luggage Says:
    February 2nd, 2020 at 11:21 am

    herschel supply co. highland luggage

    saks fifth avenue ysl card holder mount mercy universityysl love print etsyarmorstandart cullinan band 芯锌褌芯屑st gucci 3d printing case for xiaomi redmi 5 plus

  16. stetson no fly zone hat villagehatshop Says:
    February 17th, 2020 at 6:06 am

    stetson no fly zone hat villagehatshop

    red and white striped beanie cheap black diamond earrings fly fishing chest bag atlanta falcons youth pajamas army ranger cap flyby low nike nike soccer boots 2016 cr7 burberry baby sale

  17. ellen tracy kitten heel pump Says:
    February 23rd, 2020 at 1:13 pm

    ellen tracy kitten heel pump

    adidas latest kicks black baby uggs harlequins cycling jersey mouth jewelry grillz suicoke yoox crupie wheels black wedges near me zara black friday

  18. caparros vestes en jean Says:
    March 9th, 2020 at 10:02 am

    caparros vestes en jean

    adidas brillantini yeezy boost 350 asics ds trainer 21 hombre blanco le coq sportif basket femme 2014 nike elite backpacks pochette ceinture en cuir pour homme housse de coussin 30×50 serviette decathlon microfibre lunette protection pc tondeuse multif…

  19. tovaglia tavolo quadrato Says:
    March 10th, 2020 at 2:38 am

    tovaglia tavolo quadrato

    negozi scarpe milano abbigliamento twin set outlet joma top flex 709 f茅rfi teremcip艖 a n艖i retik眉l pszichol贸gi谩ja n艖k lapja scarpe vegan jeans vita alta levis elado i5 os dell laptop hero logo scribble sapka new york yankees blue yellow tunika pink kan…

  20. the north face khumbu fleece olive green xxl 60 Says:
    March 11th, 2020 at 11:08 am

    the north face khumbu fleece olive green xxl 60

    versace eros cologne mini by gianni versace 0.17 .17 oz 5 ml edt new in box north face 900 series faux leather sleeves big lapels slim coat diors latest runway bag for fall winter 2016 bagaddicts anonymous lydc london womens aria handbag shoes bags son…

  21. motorola moto pulse bluetooth headphones black Says:
    March 18th, 2020 at 10:15 pm

    motorola moto pulse bluetooth headphones black

    bottega veneta cobalt intrecciato nappa large veneta bag hobo bag info china new bags fashion mk ladies handbags china fashion bags girls green winter coat cognac bank hoek koszulka termoaktywna adidas techfit base long sleeve m 爻丕毓丕 丨乇賷賲賷 fossil golde…

  22. 銈汇儸銉儖銉笺€€銉栥儷銉炰粯銈兂銈点兂銉栥儷棰ㄣ儻銉炽償銉笺偣 濂炽伄瀛愩€€瀛愪緵鏈?銉欍儞銉兼湇 Says:
    March 20th, 2020 at 9:14 am

    銈汇儸銉儖銉笺€€銉栥儷銉炰粯銈兂銈点兂銉栥儷棰ㄣ儻銉炽償銉笺偣 濂炽伄瀛愩€€瀛愪緵鏈?銉欍儞銉兼湇

    srebrno szary srebrny edited kurtka zimowa liliana damska radzieckie budziki zegarki rosyjskie i radzieckie klub kurtki damskie 4f allegro skechers move n groove 莽ocuk spor ayakkab谋 lsk wysokiej jako艣ci mody dziewczyny wiosenny p艂aszczyk off shoulder v…

  23. givenchy perfume mens Says:
    March 26th, 2020 at 10:12 pm

    givenchy perfume mens

    nike free run commuter 2019 asics gel lyte 5 triple black nike air max 90 foot locker adidas jacket pink stripes blue denim shirt with black jeans nigel sylvester jordan 1

  24. gucci uomo handbag Says:
    March 28th, 2020 at 3:04 pm

    gucci uomo handbag

    tommy jeans tenis bota predator 18.3 ag zapatos vestir mujer planos munich massana verde militar bailarinas mujer 2015 window of religious statue shop baby location womens slippers old navy trump tells hes eager to remove director of farysays womens fl…

  25. 渭蟺蔚味 蟺伪位蟿蠈 蟺蟻慰尾伪蟿维魏喂 Says:
    March 29th, 2020 at 8:09 am

    渭蟺蔚味 蟺伪位蟿蠈 蟺蟻慰尾伪蟿维魏喂

    krovni nosa膷i za osobne automobile 370 kn agr谩rkeres艖 谩llattart谩s haszon谩llat ad谩s v茅tel ty煤k novalac prenatal kapsule a 30 nike air max 97 vapormax colgantes de corazones en crochet 褔械褉薪褘泄 褋邪褉邪褎邪薪 写谢褟 褕泻芯谢褘 viani 胁懈邪薪懈 gourmette motif 2 coeurs grav茅e…

  26. prada diagramme shoulder bag leather silver in silver Says:
    March 31st, 2020 at 5:35 am

    prada diagramme shoulder bag leather silver in silver

    auping auronde deelbaar gemak bij opmaken of schoonmaken terughaalactie adidas zwemkleding 3 strepen waarom ontbijten na acht uur slaap belangrijk is sleeplife vestito per bambini nero accanto texture derby migliori outlet occhiali da sole ray ban scar…

  27. dywan szaro be偶owy Says:
    March 31st, 2020 at 2:59 pm

    dywan szaro be偶owy

    魏喂蟿蟻喂谓伪 蠁慰蟻苇渭伪蟿伪 魏蔚蟻伪渭喂魏萎 蟺苇蟿蟻伪 蟺委蟿蟽伪蟼 渭蔚 尾维蟽畏 broil king 尾蔚谓蟿慰蠉味伪 伪蠀蟿慰魏喂谓萎蟿慰蠀 纬喂伪 伪蠁伪委蟻蔚蟽畏 尾伪胃慰蠀位蠅渭维蟿蠅谓 kinzo 7.5 x 5.5 cm 06822 sanda艂y reebok dzieci臋ce rajstopy 100 伪蟺慰魏蟻喂伪蟿喂魏畏 蟽蟿慰位畏 蟺蔚谓蟿伪渭慰蟻蠁畏 谓 286 伪蟿苇位蔚喂蠅蟿蔚蟼 慰蠀蟻苇蟼 蟽蟿畏谓 魏畏蠁喂蟽喂维 纬喂伪 蟿伪 蟽谓委魏蔚蟻 蟿慰蠀 k…

  28. tiulowa r贸偶owa sp贸dniczka warstwowa kappahl 146 Says:
    April 6th, 2020 at 11:31 pm

    tiulowa r贸偶owa sp贸dniczka warstwowa kappahl 146

    uchwyt na laptopa torba m臋ska sk贸rzana torba podr贸偶na nowo艣ci odzie偶 kobieta rozmiar g贸ra 38 promod canpol pluszowa karuzela do 艂贸偶eczka biedronki 2 315 pantalon patagonia homme patagonia duck pas cher collier oui dior femme doudoune monclers manteau r…

  29. masuta ding din lemn de stejar si sticla fumurie Says:
    May 24th, 2020 at 5:11 am

    masuta ding din lemn de stejar si sticla fumurie

    laborator electronica graduo pantofi sport adidas 8k soba sauna rusia 18 bucuresti sectorul 1 ceas de mana fossil. ceas fossil 閫佹枡鐒℃枡 澶忔柊浣?椋俱倞绱?娴磋。 鐫€鐗?鍜岃灏忕墿 甯>銈?甯磹 甯儝銉?鍜岃 銈汇兗銉?銉欍儹銈偦銉戙儸銉笺儓銈广儓銉┿儍銉椼儜銉炽儣銈?103 767 榛?moncler 銉兂銈儸銉笺儷 2018骞存槬澶?sweatsh…

  30. asics cumulus 14 Says:
    May 24th, 2020 at 3:20 pm

    asics cumulus 14

    sedia da tavolo cam siti che vendono occhiali da sole sediolina cam tessuti natale scarpe estive beige kit ricostruzione unghie professionale scarpe uomo dorate heine abend bluse goldkette juwelier hochzeitskleid verkaufen tom tailor denim parka

  31. giochi in scatola per bambini Says:
    May 24th, 2020 at 10:59 pm

    giochi in scatola per bambini

    materassi divani costumi halloween facili giochi per mare novita unghie 2016 abiti da sposa ralph lauren rolex gmt master prezzo sedie e tavoli in polyrattan braun silk epil viso cinzia soft primavera estate 2019 plafoniere da parete per interni manigl…

  32. 褋锌芯褉褌懈胁薪褘泄 褉褞泻蟹邪泻 yes vr 01 屑邪谢懈薪芯胁褘泄 泻褍锌懈褌褜 胁 泻懈械胁械 Says:
    May 25th, 2020 at 12:34 pm

    褋锌芯褉褌懈胁薪褘泄 褉褞泻蟹邪泻 yes vr 01 屑邪谢懈薪芯胁褘泄 泻褍锌懈褌褜 胁 泻懈械胁械

    锛曞垎琚栵綎銉嶃儍銈褰㈣>銉兂銉斻兗銈?銈枫儯銉炽儜銉炽偞銉笺儷銉?銉夈儸銈?鎶湶瀹?妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銉°兂銈?銉涖儻銈ゃ儓 銈儯銉冦儣銇€氳博 鍏紡 銉€銉冦儠銈c兗 銉曘儸銉炽偤 鍐仺銈儶銈广優銈广伄銈广儦銈枫儯銉偘銉冦偤 妗愯= 涓夈仱鎶樸倞 銇欍伄銇撱儥銉冦儔 銈枫兂銈般儷 銇欍伄銇?銉炪儍銉?銇欍伄銇撱優銉冦儓 grl 銈般儸銈ゃ儷 銇?銉併儱銉笺儷銉椼儶銉笺儎銈广偒銉笺儓 銈广偒銉笺儓 銆?wear geaca l spyder down iarna munte mam…

  33. Says:
    June 1st, 2020 at 3:21 am

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here on that Topic: […]

  34. usb redukce sada 7 kus暖 se slevou za 179 Says:
    June 7th, 2020 at 5:28 pm

    usb redukce sada 7 kus暖 se slevou za 179

    wedding styles for 2019 strapless dress necklines d谩mske 拧aty na jedno rameno 3219 masivn铆 slevy pietro filipi 拧aty fialov茅 d谩msk茅 拧aty greenice tessa beze拧v茅 kalhotky remeras de moda para hombres 2017 remeras corta para lacoste torba sportowa black ce…

  35. portafoglio cavalli nero Says:
    June 17th, 2020 at 11:26 pm

    portafoglio cavalli nero

    best quality female fashion handbags genuine leather crossbody bags ladies party purse for women balenciaga giant city leather tote with silver hardware in casquette foulard femme chimio mens parka black jbl earphones under 500 awesome ferret cages cat…

  36. online mobilne telefony Says:
    June 18th, 2020 at 6:33 am

    online mobilne telefony

    cauldryn fyre mobile water bottle funny dog christmas presents bull terrier dressed up pull en laine homme ralph lauren scarpe nere uomo alte cintura donna in pelle di vitello color cuoio drew shoes sandals stylish orthodic friendly shoes for men jobst…

  37. surgical hair clippers Says:
    June 23rd, 2020 at 7:08 am

    surgical hair clippers

    puma axelion black and white us navy seal hat long dress with short jacket thrift apparel website lace tulle prom dress halter dress top churidar collar neck designs catalogue under armour sc30 i can do all things ii t shirt black bei womens under armo…

  38. voir notre profil maintenant Says:
    June 25th, 2020 at 2:08 pm

    … [Trackback]

    […] There you will find 81934 more Info on that Topic: […]

  39. trouver influenceuse Says:
    June 29th, 2020 at 11:32 pm

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on that Topic: […]

  40. 바카라사이트 Says:
    July 1st, 2020 at 12:54 pm

    … [Trackback]

    […] Here you can find 51346 additional Info to that Topic: […]

  41. smykker rosaguld Says:
    July 11th, 2020 at 8:13 am

    smykker rosaguld

    sand谩ly chellysun nike d谩msk茅 boty b铆l茅 letn铆 oble膷en铆 pro miminka p谩nsk茅 p谩sky nike chicco 尾蟻蔚蠁喂魏伪 蟻慰蠀蠂伪 纬慰尾蔚蟽 谓慰蠀渭蔚蟻慰 42 畏渭喂蟺伪位蟿伪 渭蔚纬伪位伪 渭蔚纬蔚胃畏 伪谓蟿喂魏位蔚蟺蟿喂魏伪 蟽蠀蟽蟿畏渭伪蟿伪 蟽蟺喂蟿喂蠅谓 蟺伪喂未喂魏伪 伪胃位畏蟿喂魏伪 蟺伪蟺慰蠀蟿蟽喂伪 渭蔚 蠁蠅蟿伪魏喂伪 渭蟺位慰蠀味蔚蟽 渭蔚 味喂尾伪纬魏慰 north face long c…

  42. coque balenciaga note 9 Says:
    July 16th, 2020 at 2:51 pm

    coque balenciaga note 9

    doc martens dress shoes 賲賵囟丞 噩丿賷丿丞 丕賱賳爻丕亍 丕賱爻賷丿丕鬲 賵丕丨丿 丕賱賰鬲賮 兀賰賲丕賲 鬲丕賳賰 丕賱賲丨丕氐賷賱 丕賱賯賲賲 丕賱氐賷賮 鬲賲鬲丿 丕賱氐丿乇賷丞 賰丕賲賷 賯賲賲 毓丕乇囟丞 丕賱賲賱丕亘爻 丕賱亘賷囟丕亍 賲賰亘乇 氐賵鬲 亘禺丕氐賷丞 丕賱亘賱賵鬲賵孬 賯丕亘賱 賱賱賳賯賱 40 賵丕胤 賱丕爻賱賰賷 亘丕爻 丕賱毓賲賵丿 賲賯丕賵賲 賱賱賲丕亍 賮賷 丕賱賴賵丕亍 丕賱胤賱賯 丕賱賲鬲賰賱賲 丿毓賲 AUX TF USB Boo…

  43. boty puma p谩nsk茅 sleva Says:
    July 20th, 2020 at 6:32 am

    boty puma p谩nsk茅 sleva

    gadget 渭蟺伪谓喂慰蠀 蠁胃畏谓伪 伪蔚蟻慰蟺慰蟻喂魏伪 蟻伪喂谓蔚蟻 蟺位蠀谓蟿畏蟻喂伪 蟺喂伪蟿蠅谓 zanussi 纬魏蟻喂 伪胃位畏蟿喂魏伪 蟺伪蟺慰蠀蟿蟽喂伪 纬蠀谓伪喂魏蔚喂伪 beckmann madkasse gavekort zoologisk have b酶rnejakker hummel timberland sko k酶benhavn skechers koza膷ky pen臎啪enka elega ta拧ka z tri膷ka 2020 grey coatigan a…

  44. London Hotels Says:
    July 20th, 2020 at 1:44 pm

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Info here on that Topic: […]

  45. terepmint谩s r枚vidnadr谩g n艖i Says:
    July 28th, 2020 at 8:25 pm

    terepmint谩s r枚vidnadr谩g n艖i

    publicitarios econ贸micos con logo impreso lg ph450ug opiniones protector asiento moto refacciones para motos nuevo en mercado oferta cyber week carro infantil para bicicletas baby testreszabott nem sz枚v枚tt bev谩s谩rl贸t谩ska lamin谩l贸 besz谩ll铆t贸kkal minecra…

  46. el grupo de suministros industriales saltoki abre en alcoy su Says:
    July 30th, 2020 at 11:51 am

    el grupo de suministros industriales saltoki abre en alcoy su

    patron de robe 脿 manche longue et courte burda 6641 lunettes de vue de cazal en 7078 001 stan smith adidas en daim bleu nuit vinted fiocco feh茅rnem疟 szett melltart贸 茅s 4 r茅szes 谩gynem疟 garnit煤ra vid谩m elef谩nt r贸zsasz铆n sz眉rke l谩nyok expressz bikini for…

  47. precio de juegos de realidad virtual Says:
    August 1st, 2020 at 7:11 am

    precio de juegos de realidad virtual

    maillot sport manche longue stan smith vert a scratch velo giant blanc les compos officielles du match amical entre le br茅sil et l yazole f茅rfi kar贸ra barna le茅rt茅kelt menyasszony n茅met眉l eredeti footglove n艖i b艖r balerina cip艖 calvin klein feh茅r 2 cso…

  48. 10 documentaci贸n relativa a operaciones de compra venta y Says:
    August 3rd, 2020 at 1:38 am

    10 documentaci贸n relativa a operaciones de compra venta y

    parador soporte motocicleta stand trasero remonte koptatott r贸zsasz铆n cip艖 45 贸ri谩s shop nagym茅ret疟 arany delfines gy疟r疟 arany 茅kszerek verre loupe pour masque de soudage magasin de jouets lumineux vecteur vente conception flyer avec 3 pares calcetin a…

  49. caja rural seguros rga 2019 Says:
    August 4th, 2020 at 5:14 pm

    caja rural seguros rga 2019

    prix des maison ossature bois protection respiratoire sac x pack chaussure palladium saminette laces jeu de cartes foot 31 meilleures images du tableau my silver 茅kszer v谩rosk枚zpont eredeti adidas meleg铆t艖 nadr谩g 2 3 p枚tty枚s vintage ruha awilda piros h…

  50. glasgow conveyancing Says:
    August 11th, 2020 at 8:16 pm

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here to that Topic: […]

  51. URL Says:
    November 26th, 2020 at 11:48 am

    … [Trackback]

    […] Informations on that Topic: […]


You must be logged in to post a comment.