Steven Price

My book

Media Minefield


Guide to NZ Media Law

Official Information Act

Official Information Act


Bill of Rights Act

Media law resources

Feeds (RSS)

Archive for April, 2008

NZ Censor Doesn’t Stymie Grand Theft Auto Plot

Monday, April 28th, 2008

You could be forgiven for getting the opposite impression from the NZ Herald’s headline:
Censor Stymies Grand Theft Auto Plot
It rather suggests that our censor has carved out chunks of the latest version of the wildly popular - and wildly violent - video game Grand Theft Auto.
Nope.
If you read the story carefully, hang your head sideways […]

A tragic comment

Thursday, April 24th, 2008

Perhaps Objectivist Lindsay Perigo is within his rights to complain about the “media ghouls’” lack of respect for the dignity of the Mangatepopo canyoning victims’ families and friends.
But he’s drawing a long bow to blame the invasion of privacy (and the subjects’ willingness to succumb to it) on his all-purpose whipping boy, ”statism”:
It is testament to how successful […]

Soapbox: internet company ISPed off

Thursday, April 24th, 2008

Don Price, head of the Hawkes Bay internet company Wasp, wrote in to argue that ISPs are grown-up enough to develop their own industry standards:

I find it very interesting that once again we (the internet business community) through the new Copyright Act will have the unenviable privilege of the legal fraternity with their intellectual might and […]

To die like a blog

Saturday, April 19th, 2008

Poneke is reporting that blogger HotTopic has withdrawn a post criticising the Listener and its editor after receiving a (presumably defamation) threat from the magazine’s lawyers.
In its place, there’s a fullsome correction and apology (which looks to have been drafted by said lawyers).
In the comments section of the correction and apology, someone has helpfully posted a link […]

ACCURACY UNDER ATTACK

Friday, April 18th, 2008

As an occasional critic of the Press Council in the past, it would be churlish of me not to acknowledge its robust (and unanimous) ruling in a complaint I brought on behalf of the Coalition for Open Government. The complaint was mostly about the NZ Herald’s front page editorial excoriating the Electoral Finance Bill, headed […]

New notice-and-takedown regime for ISPs

Thursday, April 10th, 2008

Under the most significant provisions of the new amendments to the Copyright Act (which have been passed by Parliament but haven’t yet come into force), ISPs can be liable if their users infringe copyright. But only if:

They’ve authorised or controlled the copying; or
They’ve stored the material and know or have reason to believe it’s an […]

Indian IPL league manacles reporters

Thursday, April 10th, 2008

You can film our 20/20 matches, but you can’t put pictures on the web. Oh, and we can use any pictures you take as we like, for free.
These are the reporting conditions proposed for the IPL’s new cricket league. The UK’s Newspaper Publishers Association calls them “some of the most restrictive and burdensome access arrangements ever […]

Canadian Supreme Court to decide on new defamation defence

Thursday, April 10th, 2008

Leave has been granted for the Canadian Supreme Court to rule on whether Canada will recognise a public interest/responsible journalism defence along the lines of Reynolds in the UK (and related to the Lange cases in NZ and Australia). I discussed the Canadian Court of Appeal decision here. The Canadian decision is likely to be […]

BSA in a bind

Thursday, April 3rd, 2008

I think the BSA has broken the law.
I think they’ve done it in order to avoid breaking the law.
Confused? Let me explain. They’ve issued a decision upholding (by majority) a complaint against TVNZ’s Sunday programme on grounds of inaccuracy and unfairness. But the decision contains no reasoning. It seems this is because the reasoning cannot be […]

BSA round-up

Wednesday, April 2nd, 2008

When showing graphic footage (such as autopsy photos) on the news, the broadcaster should use a warning, and put the graphic footage far enough into the news item to give parents a chance to turn off the TV. When running a story about a campaign against child abuse, showing some photos of the beaten body […]